Loading today's hours...
Welcome to Tony’s Pizzalicious
Since 1967, Tony’s Pizzalicious has been serving Cayce generations of customers with pizza, pasta, gyros, salads, subs, and more on Knox Abbott Drive. From classic favorites to Greek specialties, there’s something for every table. Following a thoughtful renovation, the restaurant continues the Tony’s tradition while welcoming longtime guests and a new generation of diners.
Italian and Greek favorites
From Famous Spaghetti and our famous meat sauce to Dimi’s Deluxe Pizza, Val’s Vegetarian Pizza, and Greek favorites, there’s something for everyone. Try Steve’s Best Parmigiana Sub, the Italian Sausage Sub, or Greek Gyro Pizza—“Now that’s Greek! Opa!” Save room for Miss Ann’s Famous Cheesecake, homemade with cherry sauce.
Order Direct From Tony’s
Make your Tony’s favorites just a few clicks away. Order pizza, pasta, gyros, subs, and more directly online for a simple, convenient experience. Whether you’re picking up a family favourite or ordering a meal for the table, start your order anytime with the Order Online button.
A look at the table
Red booths on Knox Abbott
Tony’s has welcomed Cayce diners on Knox Abbott Drive since 1967. Inside, the warm red-and-cream setting, classic booths, and vintage-inspired signage create the feel of an old-school neighborhood pizzeria. Planning a meal with family or friends? Make a reservation ahead of time and settle in for pizza, pasta, gyros, and more in a comfortable, nostalgic setting.
Famous Meat Sauce Spaghetti
A Tony’s classic for a reason. Our Famous Meat Sauce Spaghetti brings together hearty spaghetti and Tony’s famous house meat sauce for a comforting, satisfying Italian favourite. It’s the kind of long-time favourite that has kept generations of Cayce diners coming back since 1967.
Hand-Tossed, Made From Scratch
Every Tony’s pizza starts with hand-tossed dough, homemade sauce, and a flavourful four-cheese blend. Made from scratch and never frozen, each pizza is prepared fresh for that classic Tony’s experience. From simple favourites to fully loaded specialties like Dimi’s Deluxe, there’s a pizza for every kind of fan.
Feed the Whole Crew: Tony's Catering
Planning a birthday, family gathering, office lunch, or special celebration? Let Tony’s Pizzalicious help feed the crowd with pizza, pasta, subs, gyros, and other crowd-pleasing favorites. Share your event details and catering needs with the team, and they’ll help make planning the food simple and delicious.
Weekly Specials
Mondays & Tuesdays: $9.99 Large Cheese Pizza!
Enjoy a classic Tony’s favourite at a special price.
A Story Built to Last
Tony’s Pizzalicious was built in 1967 by its original family team—a mother, father, and son who created a neighborhood spot around good food and welcoming service. In 2010, Steve purchased Tony’s and gave the restaurant a thoughtful renovation while adding new ovens. The updates brought new energy to the space while keeping the traditions and familiar favourites that generations of customers have enjoyed.
Find Us
Address: 975 Knox Abbott Dr, Cayce, SC 29033, United States
Phone: +1 803-794-5469
Hours
Monday-Saturday: 11am-8:30pm
Sundays: Closed
I went to Tony's Pizzalicious, Tuesday, April 21, 2026 on 975 Knox Abbott Dr, in Cayce, SC 29033 My experience was GREAT! Every time I go, I'm not disappointed. Tony's Pizzalicious food is so Delicious, especially the pizza ! I tried the original pizza and the barbecue pizza both were so good and The waitress did a terrific job that night, she was very nice! Definitely recommend Tony's Pizzalicious !
Traveling back home to Indiana after staying in South Carolina for a week and ran across this gem. Great service, food was out in a good time, and the taste...amazing. We are picky when it comes to meatball subs & fettuccine. Meatballs and sauce taste homemade. Large portions on everything & the price was good. Thank you for a great experience.
The Service was amazing, we ordered the meat lovers pizza and the Supreme pizza with 2 side salads and finally spaghetti they had just the right amount of sauce and we desert 20 chef kisses out of 10 👨🍳👨🍳👩🍳👩🍳
Tony's Pizzalicious Rewards
Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online and redeem your points for free food!
Reservations
We are happy to accept reservations through our website, to get started, click the link below.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are you known for?
We are known for Tzatziki, Bruschetta, Garlic Bread, Philly Cheesesteak, Roast Beef Sandwich, Grilled Chicken Salad, Greek Food, Sandwiches, Pasta, Meatballs, Salads, Cheesecake, Calzone, Stromboli, Cheese Pizza, Hawaiian Pizza, Grilled Cheese, Cheesesteak, Mozzarella Sticks, Cannoli, Spaghetti, Fettuccine Alfredo, Baklava, Chicken Alfredo, Meat Lovers Pizza, Deli Sandwiches, Chicken Salad, Lasagna, Wings, Chicken Wings, Greek Salad, and Grilled Chicken
Where are you located?
We are located in Cayce, SC at 975 Knox Abbott Dr
What areas do you serve?
We serve the following areas: West Columbia, Olympia, Cayce, Kinsler, Springdale, Arthurtown, Dixiana, Oak Grove, St. Andrews, Munster, Woodland Hills, Pine Ridge, Grenadier, Denny Terrace, Bluff Estates, Seven Oaks, Forest Acres, Sims, South Congaree, and Belmont.
Our location